Tax Litigation and Controversy
Tax controversy support assists individuals and businesses through their legal counsel in disputes with the Internal Revenue Service or state taxing authorities, including examinations, IRS Appeals, U.S. Tax Court litigation, and criminal tax matters. This work draws directly on experience gained through 25 years with IRS Criminal Investigation, providing a practitioner’s understanding of how the government builds and evaluates a tax case.
When Clients Engage This Service
You are representing a taxpayer who is the subject of a civil tax audit or criminal tax investigation and need a financial expert who understands how the government is building its case. They may have received a deficiency notice and need to challenge the numbers behind it. You’re negotiating an offer-in-compromise or collection matter where an accurate financial picture determines the outcome. Or the government has reconstructed your client’s income using an indirect method rather than relying on your actual books and records, and you need that reconstruction reviewed by someone who has built the same kind of case from the other side.
Engagement Approach
In order to protect Kovel privilege, legal counsel should engage Justin to test the validity of the government’s allegations and the soundness of their methodology. Services include reconstruction of income and expenses where books and records are incomplete, and review and rebuttal of IRS methods of proof, including the specific-items method, the bank deposits and cash expenditures method, the net worth method, and the source-and-application-of-funds method. The work also covers calculation of tax loss and civil or criminal restitution exposure, and analysis of penalty and interest computations under the Internal Revenue Code. Work is performed consistent with the AICPA Statement on Standards for Tax Services where tax positions or return-related conclusions are addressed, and the AICPA Statement on Standards for Forensic Services No. 1 where the engagement involves litigation or investigation support, including its requirements for integrity, objectivity, and clear client communication. Any representation before the IRS is conducted in accordance with Treasury Department Circular 230 (31 C.F.R. Part 10), which governs the conduct of practitioners before the IRS.
Engagement Deliverables
Justin is engaged by and works alongside legal counsel to identify factual and computational weaknesses in the government’s or opposing party’s financial analysis, prepare demonstrative exhibits for Tax Court or district court proceedings, and, where retained as a testifying expert, provide opinions that meet the admissibility requirements of Federal Rule of Evidence 702. Engagement scope, including whether the work will be discoverable or privileged under Kovel will be discussed and defined in writing with counsel before analysis begins.


