Q. What is the standard applied to damages calculations?
Plaintiffs are not entitled to speculative, overly optimistic, or unrealistic damages. Courts expect forensic accountants to establish their calculation with reasonable certainty. Put another way, sufficient evidence. The term may appear subjective, but courts have provided factors that the expert should consider in arriving at a conclusion of reasonable certainty. They include:
1. Confidence In The Accuracy Of The Estimate
Factors influencing confidence may be evidence such as emails, contract terms on future sales prices, or other documentation. Further, the business may have a clear track record of financial performance. The expert’s confidence is further demonstrated by narrowing the lost profits estimate within a defined range. If an expert relied upon several difficult-to-quantify factors, it may weaken the certainty.
2. Whether The Injured Party Suffered Damage
How well does the evidence demonstrate the defendant caused the damage? Can the damage be quantified. These are key considerations for certainty.
3. Wrongdoer Rule
While not directly related to the calculation, a wrongdoer that caused harm cannot avoid damages simply because they may be difficult to compute.
4. The Use Of The Best Evidence
This is primarily a legal concept, but for purposes of forensic accounting it becomes relevant as it relates to the quality of the calculation. For example, citing optimistic projections the plaintiff prepared for potential investors as proof of potential sales absent other supporting evidence may not meet the reasonable certainty test.
5. The Amount Of Damages
As the amount of damages increase, so does the complexity of the case, the burden placed on evidence and calculations, and the scrutiny of juries and other triers of fact.
6. Alternative Methods
Whether or not the forensic accountant considered alternative methods of calculating damages will be weighed such as documenting changes in the business value.
Q. How Are Damages Calculated?
Once a claim of breach is asserted, the forensic accountant will follow a series of steps designed to assist the relevant stakeholders with determining the proper amount of compensatory damages. Approaches are customized to the industry, legal framework, economic conditions and other factors.
The methodologies used to calculate the damage depend on the specific situation and it is common for multiple methodologies to be performed to validate each approach. A common approach is described as a “before and after” approach. This calculation seeks to establish the record of performance prior to the breach and then demonstrate how the performance was altered due to the breach. It uses actual, historical financial data to demonstrate a record of performance and works best when there is documented performance. For example, an organization with a strong record of profits prior to the contract breach may have suffered a negative impact to profits due to the breach. This can be demonstrated with a “before and after” calculation. Another common framework is the “but for” calculation which is based on the assumption that no breach occurred. To calculate damages using this framework, the expert typically uses the plaintiff’s pre-breach performance to estimate what it would have earned but for the breach, then subtracts what it actually earned. The forensic accountant must consider mitigations that the court would expect the plaintiff to have engaged in to reduce the impact of the breach and also discount the future damages amount to present value.

