When Should You Hire a Forensic Accountant?

When Should You Hire a Forensic Accountant?

by | Aug 27, 2026 | Uncategorized

Justin Campbell, CPA PLLC is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. If you require legal advice, you should consult a licensed attorney. The information provided herein is offered solely within the context of forensic accounting services and is based on methodologies and professional standards established by the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA).

Q. When Should You Hire a Forensic Accountant?
The short answer – before you think you need one. Forensic accountants are probably best known for their ability to analyze disparate data and provide clarity to their clients after an incident, but organizations that are risk-conscious should strongly consider hiring a forensic accountant before anything has happened.

Pre-incident Services
Forensic accountants can work proactively with owners and managers to design the internal control framework within their organization to mitigate the risk of financial misstatement or fraud. Forensic accountants can help design preventive and detective controls for the organization. The owners and/or management team will ultimately have the responsibility to implement an effective internal control framework. The value of this service to the organization is significant. The Association of Certified Fraud Examiner’s (ACFE) 2026 Report to the Nation states that the median amount of loss per case documented was $104,000. You may think, “My organization is small, so I probably do not need to worry.” The ACFE reported that among the cases in their report, organizations with fewer than 100 employees had a median fraud amount of $126,000.

Post-incident Services
There are a wide variety of events that require the services offered by forensic accountants. Those services are generally split into two categories – investigative and litigation. Forensic accountants are often involved in marital, business-to-business, and insurance disputes. They can also work in bankruptcy or perform fraud investigations. They also support both civil and criminal tax controversy matters. They commonly work directly with attorneys, particularly when the attorney-client privilege is important. In fact, one of the first things I will do when a non-attorney client contacts me is ascertain whether or not the client or matter would benefit from the attorney-client privilege. If so, I will likely recommend that the client hire an attorney and request the attorney to contact me for a potential engagement. When working directly for attorneys, forensic accountant’s work product and communications may be treated as privileged under the Kovel doctrine. That doesn’t mean that all engagements are with attorneys. Circumstances may dictate that a forensic accountant should work with non-attorney individuals or organizations directly.

Hiring a competent forensic accountant could be the difference between the expert’s testimony being admissible or not. Judges serve as gatekeepers during the litigation phase of disputes and will not allow expert testimony that does not adhere to law and the federal rules of evidence. I’ve testified in federal court and I can attest that judges take this role seriously. Clients should consider the qualifications, designations, and memberships of the forensic accountant when deciding whether to hire them or not. Organizations such as the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA) and Association of Certified Fraud Examiners (ACFE) have certifications to indicate expertise in forensic accounting. The AICPA offers the Certified in Financial Forensics (CFF) designation to licensed CPAs and members to note their expertise in financial forensics. The ACFE offers a Certified Fraud Examiner (CFE) designation to indicate when a member has demonstrated expertise in fraud investigations. Both organizations hold their members to high standards to ensure they remain educated on emerging topics while conducting themselves professionally and competently during engagements. This matters when litigation is a possibility. I hold both certifications.

I’ll end the answer how I started it – you probably should hire a forensic accountant before an incident happens. Think of it as an investment – a hedge against future losses. However, forensic accountants are armed with the tools to help organizations understand complex financial matters regardless of the scenario.

Justin Campbell, CPA PLLC is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. If you require legal advice, you should consult a licensed attorney. The information provided herein is offered solely within the context of forensic accounting services and is based on methodologies and professional standards established by the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA).

Q. What Can Businesses Do To Mitigate Losses From Fraud Or Unintentional Acts?
In short, quite a bit. No matter the size of your business – from small, family owned to large corporations, there is an internal control framework that is relevant. The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO) publishes the most widely used internal control framework. Organizations rely on the COSO integrated framework to guide the establishment of effective internal control. Internal controls will not prevent all risks, but when implemented effectively they can mitigate risk to an acceptable level.

The framework lists five components that organizations should implement. They are:

1. Establishing An Appropriate Control Environment
This includes how the leaders of an organization speak and act about ethics. Does the organization invest in its workforce to ensure competent, ethical professionals will be retained? Is there accountability for poor decisions or misconduct? The “tone at the top” is critical to maintaining the right environment to foster strong internal control.

2. Performing A Risk Assessment
Every organization’s operating environment is different. Each industry and business have unique inherent risks. This part of the framework relies on management to specify objectives and identify risks that may prevent or impact the organization’s ability to achieve those objectives. One of the risks that must be considered is that of fraud. During a risk assessment, management may observe that inventory is not properly secured and is susceptible to theft. An organization may identify that one of it’s operational objectives at the functional level will be to prevent the theft of inventory by employees and customers.

3. Implementing Control Activities In Response To The Risk Assessment
Management must implement specific activities designed to mitigate risks. For example, to mitigate the chance of theft of inventory, management may implement preventive controls, such as locks, and detective controls, such as periodic inventory counts.

4. Communicating Relevant Information To Key Personnel
The concept of establishing policies and communicating those policies to employees and other stakeholders is particularly important at this step. In addition to tracking inventory counts, for example, management must ensure that relevant data about that inventory and policies that describe how that data should be used is shared with appropriate personnel and they must understand how to use it. What should the receiving clerk do if a raw materials shipment doesn’t contain items listed in the bill of lading? Do they understand how that should be handled? This is where communicating relevant information supports the overall framework. How this information is communicated is equally important. A one-time email may get overlooked or forgotten, but on-boarding training for all new receiving clerks followed by recurring annual mandatory training is much more effective. Another key consideration for management is whether or not they have an internal whistleblower process that encourages employees to notify an appropriate party of potential wrongdoing.

5. Monitoring Activities To Determine Effectiveness Of The Controls
For larger organizations, an internal audit function can be very effective at ensuring that the other components of the framework are operating effectively. For smaller, organizations, it may be as simple as the owner taking on the responsibility to verify effectiveness. There are best practices and specific procedures and processes that can be implemented at this step, but they must be tailored to the organization. The most important step here is that monitoring of some sort is occurring and that the appropriate steps are being taken with the outcomes from that monitoring.

Each of these components must be present for the framework to be effective. An organization cannot simply ignore the communication piece of the framework and expect all others to perform well. With a demonstrated and sustained commitment to the principles outlined by this framework any organization can establish effective internal controls scaled to their size and complexity.

Q. What Do You Recommend To Mitigate Fraud Risk In My Organization?
Criminologist Donald Cressey is credited with introducing the concept of a fraud triangle. Three elements increase the risk of fraud – Pressure/incentive; Opportunity; and Rationalization. If all three of these elements are in place for any one individual or entity, fraud risk is heightened. The simplest way to mitigate the risk is to ensure at least one of those elements does not exist at any given time. Put another way would be to remove one leg from a three-leg stool. For example, if you have a frustrated employee that is under immense pressure due to impending deadlines or personal matters, has the opportunity to commit theft due to their access to assets, and lacks integrity – you have a heightened chance of fraud. How do we address this? The concept of restricting access to assets is one of the simplest preventative and detective methods of internal control. Using our frustrated employee example, let’s remove one of the legs. Let’s assume that the pressure on the employee will not change – the work still needs to be completed despite personal issues. Perhaps due to their own ethics, and unknown by you, they may have rationalized that theft is not bad – it is their way of getting what they are owed. Let’s control the one thing we can control – opportunity. Restricting access to assets is the answer here. You can change the scenario and remove another leg if you need to based on the situation. You may say, “what if I have a small company and I cannot remove a leg?” In that case, I recommend detective controls that will quickly flag theft if it occurs. If this employee does commit theft, is a control in place that will quickly detect the theft to mitigate losses? Prevention may not always be an option; in those cases detection needs to fill the gap.